As citizens and members of the international artistic community as well as the audience of contemporary art we firmly object to the decision made by the Minister of Culture and National Heritage of the Republic of Poland to appoint Piotr Bernatowicz to the position of the director of the Ujazdowski Castle Centre for Contemporary Art without an open competition recruitment procedure. We reject both the manner in which the appointment was carried out and the candidate chosen by the Minister.

The Ujazdowski Castle Centre for Contemporary Art is a transdisciplinary institution of international importance and a showcase for Polish contemporary art. An appointment that bypasses the competition procedure despite the existence of the necessary legal framework sets an exceptionally alarming precedent. It seems even more disturbing in the context of earlier personnel decisions that had a strong negative impact on important cultural institutions, such as the National Museum in Warsaw, Helena Modrzejewska National Stary Theatre in Kraków, and Polin Museum of the History of Polish Jews. This blatant disregard for procedures suggests that the decision was politically motivated rather than based on objective criteria such as merit. Such stance impedes any kind of dialogue about the program and development of the institution in the coming years.

Leading a large-scale institution such as the Ujazdowski Castle Centre for Contemporary Art requires not only specialized knowledge but also managerial expertise. One of the key skills in administration and supervision is a sense for diplomacy, as well as the ability to represent Poland in international contexts. Piotr Bernatowicz has no relevant experience. He has never worked closely with foreign curators nor planned an exhibition abroad. Nor is he able to demonstrate any qualifications in managing international projects, creating strategic partnerships with institutions abroad, and obtaining grants or other types of funding. Such experience should have been deemed essential in a candidate for a position this prestigious and of this importance.

The newly appointed candidate is not a successful negotiator. During his tenure as the director of the Arsenal Municipal Gallery in Poznań his actions caused a serious conflict with the curatorial section of his team and profund alienation of the local artistic community that resulted in an open letter of 76 young artists who were opposed to the renewal of his contract. A series of his disastrous decisions caused serious damage to the reputation of the gallery he was responsible for.

As a journalist and director of a public institution, Piotr Bernatowicz has on numerous occasions condoned and supported statements that can be considered hate speech. There is no room in the public sector for the artworks which target singled out social groups, misogynistic artwork (the exhibitions Strategies of Rebellion, Arsenal Municipal Gallery, 2015), or songs filled with anti-Semitic stereotyping (“Arsenał Kultury” (Arsenal of Culture) – a radio broadcast in Radio Poznań, 2017). Any artistic institution that promotes such messages risks losing its national and international audience, and perhaps a boycott.

We call upon the Minister of Culture and National Heritage Piotr Gliński not to appoint Piotr Bernatowicz to the position of the director of the Ujazdowski Castle Centre for Contemporary Art, and to carry out an open competition procedure in accordance with the appropriate standards of transparency and probity. Only an open competition will enable the candidates to demonstrate their qualifications and ability and present their programs for the Ujazdowski Castle Centre for Contemporary Art that would do justice to this renowned institution and allow it to maintain its international status.

signed by (among others)

Charles Esche, Director Van Abbemuseum, Eindhoven; Professor of University of the Arts London

Ferran Barenblit, Director MACBA Museu d’art Contemporani de Barcelona

Zdenka Badovinac, Director of Moderna Galerija, Ljubljana

Krist Gruithuijsen, Director Kunstwerke, Berlin

Annie Fletcher, Director Irish Museum of Modern Art, IMMA, Dublin

Ekaterina Degot, Director and Chief Curator Steirischer Herbst, Austria

Cosmin Costinas, Director Para Site, Hong Kong

Dirk Snauwaert, Director, WIELS, Brussels

Zoë Gray, Chief Curator, WIELS, Brussels"

Guy Gypens, Director of Kaaitheter, Brussels

Kathleen Van Langendonck, Artistic Director of Kaaitheater, Brussels

Jan Goossens, Director Festival de Marseille

Bart De Baer, Director M HKA, Antwerp

Övul Durmusoglu, Guest Professor Univesität der Künste Graduate School, Berlin Academy of Arts and Science), Berlin

dr Vytautas Michelkevicius, Head of doctoral programme in Fine Art, VDA , Vilnius

Lucy R. Lippard, independent curator

Hal Foster, art critic

Martha Rosler, artist, Professor II Emerita, Rutgers University

Naeem Mohaiemen, artistAnselm Franke, curator

Manuel Borja-Villel

dr Jesus Carrillo, Lecturer of Contemporary Art History, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

dr Gregory Sholette, prof. Queens College Art Department "

dr Suhail Malik, Programme Co-Director, MFA Fine Art, Goldsmith College w Londynie

dr Simon Sheikh, programme director of MFA in Curating, Goldmith's College, London

prof. Dr. Hans Abbing. visual artist and economist, professor emeritus in art sociology at the University of Amsterdam

Nanette Yannuzzi-Macias, Professor Oberlin College & Conservatory, USA

Cindi Katz, Professor, Earth and Environmental Sciences and Environmental Psychology Programs, New York

prof. Zoe Beloff, Department of Media Studies, Queens College

dr Vasyl Cherepanyn, Head of the Visual Culture Research Center / Kyiv Biennial

dr Yaiza Hernández Velázquez, Goldsmiths, University of London

dr Marcus Verhagen, Senior Lecturer, Sotheby's Institute of Art

Jason E. Bowman FRSA, Master of Fine Art Programme Leader, Valand Academy: Artistic Practice in Film, Photography, Fine Art and Literature at the University of Gothenburg.

Nanette Yannuzzi-Macias, Professor of Art, Profesor Oberlin College & Conservatory, USA

Luisa Santos, researcher and professor of Cultural Studies at the Faculty of Human Sciences, Universidade Católica Portuguesa"

Dirk De Wit, Coördinator internationale relaties en beeldende kunsten, Kunstenpunt / Flanders Arts Institute

William Menking, Editor In Chief, The Architect's Newspaper, New York

Martha Kirszenbaum, curator of French Pavilon at 58th Venice Biennale

Iliana Fokianaki, curator and director State of Concept, Athens

Livia Paldi, curator Project Art Centre, Dublin

Rachel Dedman, curator Victoria and Albert Museum, London

Matteo Lucchetti, curator Visible Project, Cittadellarte-Fondazione Michelangelo Pistoletto/Fondazione Zegna

Oier Etxeberria, Head of the Contemporary Art department in Tabakalera, Donostia-San Sebastian

Katia Krupennikova, co-curator Bergen Assembly 2019

Marilia Loureiro, curator, Casa do Povo, Sao Paulo

Nini Palavandishvili, curator, GeoAir, Tbilisi

Dóra Hegyi, curatorTranzit.hu, Budapest

Dimitry Vilensky, artist, Chto Delat

Ula Sickle, artist

Miet Warlop, artist

Jos van der Pol, artist

Maria Loboda, artist

Eva Kotatkova, artist